|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
Mumbai, a city already battling shrinking green cover, rising temperatures, and frequent flooding, is witnessing fresh outrage as thousands of trees are being cut or marked for felling across different parts of the metropolitan region. Social media claims suggesting that around 4,500 trees are being cut have triggered public anger, protests, and renewed debate over the cost of development versus environmental survival in India’s financial capital.
What Is Actually Happening in Mumbai?
The large-scale tree cutting is not linked to a single project but is the cumulative result of multiple infrastructure and urban expansion projects underway in Mumbai and its surrounding areas. These include:
- Coastal road expansion projects
- Metro rail corridors
- Road widening and flyover construction
- Redevelopment of slum and residential zones
- Clearing of mangrove areas for connectivity projects
While some viral posts mention 4,500 trees, official estimates from court proceedings and civic authorities suggest that the actual number of trees impacted across projects runs into tens of thousands, especially when mangroves are included.
The Coastal Road and Mangrove Controversy
One of the biggest contributors to the current outrage is the Versova–Bhayandar Coastal Road project, which has received conditional approval from the Bombay High Court. As per official submissions:
- Over 45,000 mangrove trees may be affected during construction
- Mangroves are legally protected and act as natural flood barriers
- Environmentalists argue their loss could worsen urban flooding and coastal erosion
Authorities have promised compensatory afforestation, but critics point out that mangroves cannot simply be replaced elsewhere, as their ecological function is location-specific.
Why the ‘4,500 Trees’ Figure Is Circulating
The figure of 4,500 trees appears to stem from:
- Older incidents of mangrove destruction in nearby regions like Uran
- Smaller municipal permissions granted for localized projects
- Aggregated numbers from different wards and road projects
Experts clarify that while 4,500 trees may reflect a phase or segment, the overall environmental impact is far larger.
Citizens, Activists, and Celebrities React
Mumbai residents, environmental groups, and climate activists have taken to the streets and social media, raising concerns that:
- Mumbai’s per-capita green space is already below global standards
- Tree cutting directly increases urban heat island effects
- Loss of green cover worsens air pollution and respiratory illnesses
- Development decisions are often taken without adequate public consultation
Hashtags demanding transparency and sustainability have been trending, with calls for authorities to explore eco-friendly alternatives.
What Authorities Are Saying
Civic bodies and project authorities maintain that:
- Tree cutting is being done with legal permissions
- Each felled tree will be compensated by multiple new plantations
- Infrastructure growth is essential for Mumbai’s future mobility
However, environmental experts argue that saplings cannot replace mature trees that have taken decades to grow.
A Bigger Question: Development at What Cost?
Mumbai’s situation reflects a national dilemma can urban development continue without destroying ecological balance?
With climate change already amplifying floods, heatwaves, and unpredictable weather, experts warn that reducing green buffers could push the city towards irreversible environmental damage.
What Happens Next
- Legal petitions challenging tree felling are still ongoing
- Courts have demanded periodic reports on afforestation
- Citizen groups are pushing for independent environmental audits
The coming months will determine whether Mumbai’s growth story can coexist with its environmental responsibilities or whether the city will pay a far heavier price in the years ahead.
